Comparison of Editorials

Assignment 2DiscussionComparison of Editorials In this assignment, you will identify and explore your splanchnic critical thinking strategies. It is the starting point to developing the skills to analyze schooling critically. Research methods of identifying strong and weak arguments using your textbook and the Argosy University online library re inceptions. Be indisputable to coer the following * delineate premises and conclusions * Discuss whether or not an inference is warranted * Discuss matters of fairness and consistencyFor this assignment, your facilitator will assign you nonpareil of the following debates * view 1 Should the Ashley X treatments have been permitted? * Debate 2 Is Osama salt away Ladens death a decisive transposition to Al Qaeda or an unmitigated victory over against terrorism? to each one debate has two rates of articles for review. Your facilitator will assign you one of these sets. Each set has two articles with two varying, but important, perspec tives on the same subject. Be sure to read both articles in the set. Debate 1These pairs of articles rivet on the subject of Ashley X, a tyke with passive encephalopathy who underwent radical surgical procedures to facilitate her care and, thereby, ostensibly repair her quality of life. Set A * Lewis, J. (2007, January 6). The moral line in medication shifts once again. The Independent, p. 37. (ProQuest Document ID 311096455). http//search. proquest. com. libproxy. edmc. edu/docview/311096455/ compend? source=fedsrch&accountid=34899 * Singer, P. (2007, January 26). A convenient verity Op-Ed. The rising York Times. (ProQuest Document ID 433487228). ttp//search. proquest. com. libproxy. edmc. edu/docview/433487228/ abstract? source=fedsrch&accountid=34899 Set B * Lindemann, H. , Nelson, J. L. (2008). The squeeze of the family. The Hastings Center Report, 38(4), 1921. (ProQuest Document ID 222368438). http//search. proquest. com. libproxy. edmc. edu/docview/222368438? accounti d=3489 9 * Picard, A. (2007, January 11). Its wrong to keep disabled girl as an angel. The Globe and Mail, p. A. 17. (ProQuest Document ID 383481551). http//search. proquest. com. libproxy. edmc. edu/docview/383481551/abstract? ource=fedsrchaccountid=34899 Debate 2 These pairs of articles focus on the subject of Osama put in Ladens death and the so-called implications his death are expected to have on matters of future Al Qaeda activity and international safety. Set A * Clarke, R. A. (2011, May 3). Bin Ladens dead. Al Qaedas not Op-Ed. The raw(a) York Times, p. A. 23. (ProQuest Document ID 864311946). http//search. proquest. com. libproxy. edmc. edu/docview/864311946/abstract? source=fedsrchaccountid=34899 * Soufan, A. H. (2011, May 3). The end of the Jihadist dream Op-Ed. The vernal York Times, p.A. 23. (ProQuest Document ID 864311556). Retrieved from http//search. proquest. com. libproxy. edmc. edu/docview/864540238/abstract? source=fedsrchaccountid=34899 Set B * Clarke, R. A . (2011, May 3). Bin Ladens dead. Al Qaedas not Op-Ed. The New York Times, p. A. 23. (ProQuest Document ID 864311946). http//search. proquest. com. libproxy. edmc. edu/docview/864311946/abstract? source=fedsrchaccountid=34899 * Nocera, J. (2011, May 3). 4 questions he leaves idler Op-Ed. The New York Times, p. A. 23. (ProQuest Document ID 864311864). http//search. proquest. om. libproxy. edmc. edu/docview/864311864/abstract? source=fedsrchaccountid=34899 Respond to the following * Identify and rationalise the strongest argument in each article. Or * Identify and explain the weakest argument in each article. Give reasons and examples from your research in victuals of your response. Write your initial response in 12 paragraphs. rehearse APA standards to citation of sources. By Saturday, April 13, 2013, mark your response to the appropriate Discussion Area. done Wednesday, April 17, 2013, review and comment on at least two peers responses. Debate 1These pairs of articles focus on the subject of Ashley X, a child with static encephalopathy who underwent radical surgical procedures to facilitate her care and, thereby, ostensibly improve her quality of life. Set A * Lewis, J. (2007, January 6). The moral line in medication shifts once again. The Independent, p. 37. (ProQuest Document ID 311096455). http//search. proquest. com. libproxy. edmc. edu/docview/311096455/abstract? source=fedsrchaccountid=34899 * Singer, P. (2007, January 26). A convenient truth Op-Ed. The New York Times. (ProQuest Document ID 433487228). http//search. proquest. com. libproxy. edmc. du/docview/433487228/abstract? source=fedsrchaccountid=34899 Set B * Lindemann, H. , Nelson, J. L. (2008). The romance of the family. The Hastings Center Report, 38(4), 1921. (ProQuest Document ID 222368438). http//search. proquest. com. libproxy. edmc. edu/docview/222368438? accountid=34899 * Picard, A. (2007, January 11). Its wrong to keep disabled girl as an angel. The Globe and Mail, p. A. 17. (ProQue st Document ID 383481551). http//search. proquest. com. libproxy. edmc. edu/docview/383481551/abstract? source=fedsrch&accountid=34899 Identify premises and conclusions Discuss whether or not an inference is warrantedDiscuss matters of truth and consistency Debate 1 Should the Ashley X treatments have been permitted? After schooling all the articles, I believe that the Ashley X treatments should have been permitted. All leavens requisite what is in the surmount interest of their child, even though sometimes they stack make mis puddles like all people. I am a parent and I could not imagine going through what Ashleys parents go through every single day. If my child was like that I hypothesis that I would probably do the same thing because having a child have a full big(a) body but the object of a 3 month old baby gagenot be a good thing.As parents, you have to protect your children the best way that you know how. The parents differentiate that what they have done to Ashley i s not for their convenience but for the girls comfort. They say the aesculapian procedures are not cruel rather, what is grotesque is having a fully grown fertile woman endowed with the mind of a baby (Andre, 2007). in that respect are many different types of fallacies and they are the straw man, attacks on character, post hoc, begging the question, appeal to popular belief, overhasty generalization, irrelevant appeal to authority, over simplification, appeal to tradition, and false dichotomy.When reading through these articles, I see hasty generalization. I know that everyone has their own opinions but there are also facts to this case. Once you start tinkering with nature, where do you decide to draw the line if at all? As Ash-leys father points out, All medicine is about interfering with nature. Why not let cancer spread and nature take its course? Why give antibiotics for infections? Science has kept Ashley alive wherefore shouldnt it be used to make her more comfortable (Lewis, 2007)? Modern medicine may save us from immediate tragedy, but only at the cost of our ethical peace of mind.We react violently to stories such as Ashleys because we are afraid of the miracles we have wrought. Where once there was just divinity and fate, now we face an endless panorama of impossible life-and-death decisions (Lewis, 2007). With this statement, What matters in Ashleys life is that she should not suffer, and that she should be able to hump whatever she is undefended of enjoying. Beyond that, she is precious not so much for what she is, but because her parents and siblings hump her and care about her.Lofty talk about human dignity should not stand in the way of children like her getting the treatment that is best both for them and their families (Singer, 2007). , I completely agree with what was said here. For any somebody in this world, we should all be able to enjoy whatever we can no matter what the situation is. In Ashleys case, being that she has the expectation of a 3 month old it would be hard to enjoy the life of an adult. References Lewis, J. (2007, Jan 06). The moral line in medicine shifts once again EDITORIAL OPINION. The Independent. Retrieved from